Wednesday, January 28, 2015

It's not a Sunni- Shi’a Conflict, dummy!


Last week, my young cousin in the second grade ran inside after an explosion shook the windows. “I don’t mind when the house shakes, I just don’t want to die in it,” he said out of breath. “You won’t.” I reassured him. He then went back to play. I followed him outside to find a group of children playing a political game: President Hadi v. Abdulmalik Al-Houthi. Their mission was to free the cats held hostage. As I sat there watching this game unfold, I heard them throw many terms around: democracy, justice, national dialogue conference etc. The words Sunni or Shi’a, were never mentioned.

This is not surprising given the fact that affiliation to a madhab (religious school of thought) rarely comes up in conversations in Yemen. This is slowly changing, and many fear that this historic diversity and tolerance might become something of the past.

To say there are no sectarian tendencies or cleavages in Yemen is incorrect (as Dr. Shelagh Weir explained from the 1980s), but the oversimplification of explaining the current power struggle entirely on historic theological differences between Sunnis and Shi’as is incorrect as well.

This is incorrect for a variety of reasons that I will summarize here.

First, while no statistics have been collected on the composition of Ansarullah, commonly known as Houthis; it is believed that many of their members are Zaydi but also come from various religious schools of thought in Shi’a and Sunni Islam, including Ismaili, Shafiʿi, and Ja’afari. Many Sunni tribesmen and soldiers have also joined the Houthis and fight along their side. In fact, prominent Shafi’i leaders like Saad Bin Aqeel, a Mufti of Ta’iz, are amongst Houthis’ leaders and in fact presented a Friday sermon at one of the sit-ins prior to their advance into the capital.

Second, Zaydis share similar doctrines and jurisprudential opinions with Sunni scholars. As Helen Lackner, author of Why Yemen Matters? stated “this has little, if anything, to do with theological differences or a Sunni/Shi’a split, but is based on issues of social cohesion, including tribal allegiance, power, control and (the absence of) development and social security funding for an increasingly impoverished and suffering population.”

Third, socially speaking Yemenis have lived and continue to live together without segregation. Muslims in Yemen, from the various schools of thought, whether Sunni or Shi’a, pray side-by-side, people intermarry without any special procedures or “conversions,” and communal violence based on confessional membership has been rare.

Fourth, according to Houthis’ their actions do not aim “exclusively or even primarily at establishing a Zaydi political order” as Stacey Phillbrick Yadav, Associate Professor and author of “Islamists and the State: Legitimacy and Institutions in Yemen and Lebanon” states. She adds, “Similarly, the fact that Islah’s membership is predominantly Sunni doesn’t mean it is working to reestablish the caliphate.”

Fifth, not all Zaydis are Houthis. Well-known Zaydi scholars and religious centers have been divided on their stance towards the Houthis.

Sixth, missing from the analysis is the link between rural deprivation and wider political contestations, and conflicts. The longer the transitional government ignored people’s grievances, the more the ranks of the discontented swelled. Last straw was when the government lifted the fuel subsidies overnight without warning in 29 July 2014, increasing the price of fuel and diesel by 60 and 90 percent. Mass protests erupted, and Houthis capitalized on these grievances, and by so doing, gained a significant number of new membership from various bacgrounds (not only Zaydis) which helped them expand.

Seventh, while sectarian cleavages are becoming exploited by various groups, such as when al-Qaeda uses the rise of Houthis to recruit more people to defend “the Sunnis," it is important to remember that those fighting al-Qaeda are not all Shi’a nor are they all Houthis.

Eigth, if this was a sectarian issue, Saleh (who is technically Zaydi) would not have engaged in six wars with the Houthis from 2004 - 2010. It appears that today’s former enemies have formed a temporary alliance.  This indicates that these conflicts are political in nature.

Ninth, there is no sectarian dimension to the victims of the violations by the Houthis such as the detention of activists and journalists in recent protests.

Finally, while the geopolitical tensions between the various political camps of course impacts what is happening on the ground, it is incorrect to explain the political dynamics in the country as simply foreign interference. In addition, narrowly framing the ongoing issue as sectarian absolves the transitional government from their duties as it helps them blame everything on foreign actors, rather than making them accountable for the localized grievances found throughout the majority of Yemen. It also absolves Houthis from the violations they have committed blaming their actions on theological differences instead of political aspirations.

As these ten points demonstrate, the issue cannot be reduced to a theological war. Analysis must include these nuances in order to better understand the ongoing political dynamics. Without a proper understanding, policies will continue to be flawed and no solutions will be formulated, which would perpetuate the cycle of violence.



35 comments:

Unknown said...

That was very eye opening. I had no idea for example that Houthis were Zaydis among them. I thought they were mostly 12'ers. I was also surprised to learn that Sunnis are in their ranks.

Thank you for sharing this. Most helpful in understanding the situation. May Allah ease the suffering of the people of Yemen

Tanya said...

Thanks for this article, fantastic!

Marc Springer said...

Great article. It goes a long way showing how the conflict is not, at its base, sectarian. Many are pushing in that direction because it serves their agenda. If you read mainstream Arabic press you would think the Houthis are mostly 12ers, a trojan horse for Iran.

Unknown said...

Happy that this article helped shed some light, and hope that we continue to have these kind of discussions, learn from each other, and try to do our best for people of Yemen, and for all humanity. we're all one after all :-)

fromsana said...

Good Article,
Last 4 yeras i was living in sana'a and what explain here is same as my analysis about the Yemen Revolution, still I beleive all these present gimmik going on by support of Ex- Dictator, without his support no one can't do anything.
I am just copying your article to my blog with your permission :)

Unknown said...

Thank you for your commentary, which I appreciated very much.

However, I would have said much the same about Iraq and Syria, particularly Iraq, which I know well. Before the war(s), I would have said that there's no chance of those countries dissolving into sectarian hatred, but they did. Iraqi Shi'a married Sunni without question. There was no discussion of sectarian belonging.

I hope it doesn't happen in Yemen.

Unknown said...

Thanks Abu izzah, and yes sure you have my permission.

Alastair, i believe that most "sectarian" conflicts around the world are really about power in essance, yet religious discourse is used to recruit people in their camps. of coruse this is this fear in Yemen that it would develop, and as i said, things are already changing a bit unfortunately. Yet, it is not the case just yet, so we should not already say it is. that would just be factually in correct. Also, the differences between the Zaydi school of thought and the Shafi'i or Hanafi schools are not that great which could minimize the potential for this to escalate into a "sectarian" war. Yet the more the media says it is, the more it might become. We just need to say it enough times for it to become a reality.

maysaa said...

It's a good article. I agree with the whole idea, but I need to clarify two thing: 1- Mufti Ta'aiz that you mentioned, visited Iran many times, and his ideas were semi twelve. He led a prayer to Huthis, actually it doesn't mean a lot as most of the mass are northern- Zaydi.
Secondly, I believe that the political conflicts always need a banner to monopolize such as nation or sect. So, you can see the case from this perspective, Huthis and their enemies used the religion/ sect to convince the youth to fight. This always creates a social tense and at some point, people may forget all their past tolerant life and categorized each other and the hatred feeling spread.

Unknown said...

Thanks Mayssa, i agree with you that groups will often use religion to justify and persuade their followers. Regarding the mufti, just because he visited Iran doesn't mean he officially became a twelver. if you have evidence of this please do share that information. The visit and the Iran alliance is a perfect example of the political alliance - Russia, China, Iran & the Houthis.

Unknown said...

pls stop killing each other,build your country together.it is just nonsence if we kill each other,just ask every body how u can fight against those who capture palistine.u people knows quran better than us, look wat says quran.put down u arms for your children and children,s children.give better yaman to your coming jeneration,vialance agresson,bullet,bum is not soluation.just luv u country otherwise foreign power will rule you.

INVEST WITH $200 AND GET A RETURNS OF $2,000 said...

Invest with 200$ and get a returns of 5,000$ within seven business working days.
Why wasting your precious time online looking for a loan? When there is an opportunity for you to invest with 200$ and get a returns of 5,000$ within seven business working days. Contact us now for more information if interested on how you can earn big with just little amount. This is all about investing into Crude Oil and Gas Business.

Email: investmoneyoilgas@gmail.com

Gabile said...

Gay Sohbet
Eşcinsel Sohbet
gabile Sohbet
gabile
gabile mobil
cinsel Sohbet

gabile Sohbet
gabile
gabile mobil
cinsel Sohbet
Eşcinsel Sohbet
Gay Sohbet

gay Sohbet
eşcinsel Sohbet
travesti Sohbet
lezbiyen Sohbet
gey Sohbet
lez Sohbet
Gabile Sohbet
Yetişkin Sohbet
+18 Sohbet
cinsel Sohbet

VIP Lahore Girls said...

Hi Dear,
you are shared good post
Call Girls in Lahore
Escorts in Lahore
Lahore Escorts

Anonymous said...

We are providing VIP cheap escort service in agar(MP).
#1 biggest site of MP. The Agar call girls’ workings with us are highly educated and professionally who will fully fulfil you. Our purpose is to supply you with a completely diversion.

http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-agar.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-alirajpur.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-anuppur.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-ashoknagar.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-balaghat.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-barwani.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-betul.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-bhind.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-bhopal.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-burhanpur.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-chhindwara.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-damoh.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-datia.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-dewas.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-Dhar.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-dindori.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-guna.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-harda.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-hoshangabad.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-indore.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-jabalpur.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-jhabua.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-katni.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-khandwa.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-malwa.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-mandsaur.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-morena.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-narsinghpur.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-neemuch.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-panna.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-raisen.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-rajgarh.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-ratlam.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-rewa.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-sagar.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-vidisha.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-satna.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-sehore.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-shahdol.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-sheopur.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-shivni.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-shivpuri.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-sidhi.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-singrauli.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-tikamgarh.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-ujjain.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-khargone.html
http://www.callgirlinmp.com/call-girl-in-umariya.html

Kriti Sharma said...

Today, when I saw your article, I felt that we are in a different world. It seems like this is a dream, I love articles like this, I also feel that I should do it too but I can't do it 'Your article is really amazing.
Call Girls Gurgaon
Call Girls Shushant Lok
Call Girls Golf Course Road
Escorts Girls Sector 2
Escorts Girls Sector 1
Escorts Girls Sector 3

Kriti Sharma said...

Your article is very good and very different. Your post will be very useful for me because I like these articles very much, I am thankful that I found this post.
Rent Call Girls In Gurugram
Rent Escorts Service
Call Girls Golf Course Road
Escorts Service Aerocity
Call Girls Huda City Center
Call Girls Sector 29
call Girls M.G. Road

Bed Pari Bangalore Escorts said...

Thanks for sharing this brilliant article it was a very useful and helpful article.

BTM layout escorts
HMT Layout Escorts
escorts services in bannerghatta
russian escorts in bangalore
Bangalore Escorts
VIP Escorts Bangalore
Call Girls in Bangalore

Anjali Singh said...

Our female escort in Lucknow love meeting new people and develop suggestive and fulfilling relationship with them.
Call girl in Lucknow

luxuryescortsinlebanon said...

Beirut escorts are running across the country and it is legal and regulated in Lebanon. It is one of the most popular
identities of the Arabian countries. Beirut is also one of the most famous cities with busty call girls in an Arabian
country named Lebanon and there are various escort service agencies as well as independent escorts across the country.
Escort in Lebanon
Escorts Lebanon
Escort Lebanon
Lebanon Escorts
Lebanon Escort
Escorts in Lebanon

Bed Pari Bangalore Escorts said...

Thanks for sharing this brilliant article it was a very useful and helpful article.

Bangalore Escorts
Banaswadi Escorts
Call Girls in Vijaynagar
Celebrity escorts bangalore
Russian Escorts in Bangalore
whitefield escorts
Call Girls in Bangalore

Jubilee Hills Hotel Services in Hyderabad said...

Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad Escorts

Escorts in Islamabad said...

Welcome to VIP Murree Escorts Agency, we are providing Pakistan's most beautiful girls if you want to spend a night with the best beauty of Murree Pakistan then you come to the right place. VIP Murree Escorts

Escorts in Murree
Murree Escorts
Escorts Murree
Escorts Service in Murree
Escorts Service Murree
Escorts Services in Abbottabad
Call Girls in Abbottabad

starport said...

The harvest season is from late August to mid-October. The clusters are conical, weighing 500-550 g, and the fruits are yellow-green colored large fruits mixed with yellow, and have a short oval shape of 12-14 g.
스포츠토토

Technical Support Services said...

There are a few ways you can install and configure your Linksys extender but the web-based method is the best. As a result of its broadness, you will be able to touch on many of its advanced settings. Begin by typing http extender Linksys com into the URL address bar.
how to setup a wifi extender

John Watson said...

If the present state of your WiFi extender is not good enough in terms of connection and speed, you might want to consider installing the Dlink WiFi extender in your home. Configure and complete the setup through Dlinkap.local, to keep enjoying the unstoppable speed that is offered by Dlink.
D'link Wifi Extender setup

John Watson said...

Are you stuck in the middle of your Orbi router setup? Well, you might want to try using the web based method to complete your setup. So connect your computer to the Orbi network, open the browser and type in orbilogin.com into the web link bar and load the page.

Anonymous said...

The 64-bit version is installed by default, unless Office detects that you already have a 32-bit version of Office (or a stand-alone Office application such as Project or Visio) installed. In this case, the 32-bit version of Office will be installed instead. To switch from a 32-bit version to a 64-bit version or vice versa, you must first uninstall Office, including any stand-alone Office applications you own, such as Project of Visio. microsoft365.com/setup

oncasinosite 카지노사이트 said...

Impressive!Thanks for giving me an idea to my site. Ill be following your works from now on. Hoping for your success.Everyone loves what you guys are up too. This type of clever work and coverage! Keep up the great works guys I’ve incorporated you guys to my own blogroll. Feel free to visit my website; 토토

quaronnejacobsmeyer said...

Casino de Commembox Casino - 나비효과.com
Casino 세종특별자치 출장마사지 de Commembox 양주 출장샵 Casino. Casino de Commembox Casino. 안성 출장샵 Casinos de Commembox Casino. Casinos de Commembox 바카라사이트 Casino. 하남 출장마사지 Casinos de Commembox Casino. Casinos de

Printer Customer Help said...

It's hard to find the best hp printer installation and hp printer repair service, But you don't have to worry for that as you've already found it. We are the specialized team of experts who are particularly skilled in this domain and we'd be more than happy to help you with your problems.

Extender Linksys said...

To set up your Tp Link router, you need to login to the
Tp Link router setup interface. Enter the default internal IP 192.168.1.1 in the web address and then put down the router login username and password on the login page. Go to the Tp Link router setup wizard and follow the on-screen instructions to configure the router.

Diamondexch said...

One of the top fantasy cricket applications in India in 2022, also known as world777, provides one of the best fantasy cricket gameplays. Users can play and earn incentives without building a fantasy team by simply picking the match's winner.

Boe Robbie said...

Accessed quality feeder cattle for sale in Montana by visiting livestock auctions. ConneXion Livestock is a sales platform, connecting buyers and sellers of cattle on just one site. Sellers can list their cattle on our website, and buyers can place bids on each type of cattle. Visit our website to learn more about our services.

vral times said...

Way cool! A few praiseworthy examinations! I regard you making this article what's more the rest of the site is limitless.


https://www.producthunt.com/@tech_fury

spotifypairactivate said...

Thank you for sharing excellent informations.Your site is so cool.I am impressed by the details that you’ve on this blog.for more information You can check my website.you can Get more new latest updates about my sites.so follow and click my below link.
spotify.com/pair
Fubo tv connect